Why artists can’t ignore vanity metrics

Streams, likes, and followers are branding assets.

If you are not a subscriber of The Fanbase Builder, join 1.000+ artists, creators, and music industry executives who receive it for free.

Let’s dive into today’s topic:

---

Why artists can’t ignore vanity metrics

Music industry gatekeepers base their decisions on easily inflated data.

Why it matters

In marketing, the distinction between vanity metrics and actionable metrics is well established.

• Vanity metrics like followers, streams, and likes are easy to inflate, straightforward to polish, and reveal little about genuine audience behaviour.

• Actionable metrics, such as video watch time, save rates, or ticket sales, reflect real human behaviour showing intent.

Experienced marketers know this. The problem is that most music industry gatekeepers aren’t running the same analysis.

For example: A booking agent deciding whether to sign an emerging artist may look at Spotify monthly listeners. A label A&R might check Instagram follower counts. A festival promoter weighing a guarantee could look at streaming numbers.

None of these are deep engagement signals, but they are publicly visible, instantly available, and fast to interpret. In an industry where a decision-maker evaluates dozens of artists a week, vanity metrics become shorthand.

Hence, vanity metrics are a branding asset, and artists can’t dismiss them outright.

Generated with Gemini.

How it works

Vanity metrics are easy to manipulate. I am not recommending any of the following tactics as examples. However, understanding how they work is useful, both for protecting yourself from being impressed by inflated numbers and for understanding why organic growth signals are harder to fake.

• Streams (any platform): Land a placement on a passive-listening playlist: a concentration playlist, a sleep channel, a background music compilation. Listeners aren’t following the tracklist; they want ambient sound, not artists. The streams accumulate without building an audience.

• YouTube video views: Run a skippable pre-roll campaign on YouTube targeting Smart TVs. Millions of people use this channel as their main music source. Most viewers don’t actively skip; it’s too much hassle. They’re unlikely to search for the artist’s name or click through. The views-to-comments ratio tells the real story.

• Social media followers or likes: Run ads targeting the cheapest available markets. The follower count rises, but the engagement rate drops. Future organic reach won’t grow as much because algorithms don’t pay much attention to followers in the long run.

Each of these tactics inflates the number without building the fanbase. More importantly, experienced gatekeepers recognise the patterns.

Yes, but..

We can’t fully blame industry pros for relying on vanity metrics.

First, actionable metrics are private. They have to be requested from the artist, and who’s to say the numbers supplied haven’t been selectively presented? Vanity metrics are the only publicly verifiable data available.

Second, decision-makers are moving fast. What feels like a life-changing opportunity to one emerging artist is a routine call for the person on the other side of the table. Running a deep engagement analysis on every artist takes time nobody actually has.

Third, and this is the most encouraging part, the best decisions in music aren’t made on data. They’re made by ear. The most experienced gatekeepers trust their listening, the scene an artist belongs to, and a quality of appeal that doesn’t show up in any spreadsheet. Those qualitative signals are the most actionable metrics of all.

Vanity metrics get artists in the room, but what happens in the room depends on everything that data can’t measure.

Take action now

Artists can run a cold gatekeeper read on their own profile. Open a private browser window, search your artist name, and look at what a booking agent or A&R would see in the first thirty seconds. Ask what impression those numbers make before anyone has heard a single note.

Your thoughts

Further reading

• Finding the metrics that matter (The Fanbase Builder)

• Artists shouldn’t rush releasing music to streaming platforms (The Fanbase Builder)

• Why artists shouldn’t skip steps (The Fanbase Builder)

• Artists should focus on only two metrics (The Fanbase Builder)

• How to leverage user intent (The Fanbase Builder)